Commonwealth Fund: U.S. Healthcare is Lagging Behind Other Countries

Janice Simmons, for HealthLeaders Media , November 5, 2009

When it comes to paying for healthcare, the United States—when compared with 10 other industrialized countries—tops the list as having the highest spending per capita ($7,290), while lagging behind those nations in access, quality, and use of health information technology, according to the Commonwealth Fund's 12th annual international health policy survey.

The spending per capita was 50% more than the next highest country, Norway ($4,762), and triple the rate of the lowest country compared with in the study, New Zealand ($2,510), according to the survey that appears Thursday in an online issue of Health Affairs. More than 10,000 primary care physicians were surveyed this year in the countries that also include: Australia, Canada, France, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands, Sweden, and the United Kingdom.

"An overriding message of this survey ... is that access barriers, lack of information, inadequate financial support for preventive and chronic care undermine primary care doctors' efforts to provide timely high quality care," said Karen Davis, the Commonwealth Fund's president, at a telebriefing discussing the findings. This puts "the U.S. far behind what other countries are achieving."

"The concept of the patient-centered chronic care model using teams [and] engaging patients to help prevent complications originated in the U.S. But we find such efforts are spreading faster in other countries," said Commonwealth Fund Senior Vice President Cathy Schoen, a lead author of the article. "We need to close the performance gap for the health of the nation."

Among the areas examined in the survey are:

Access and Barriers to Care. More than half of American physicians (58%) reported their patients had difficulties paying for medications or other out of pocket costs, compared to between 5% and 37% in the other countries.

U.S. physicians also were four times or more as likely as physicians in some other countries—Australia, Netherlands, Sweden, and the U.K.—to report major problems with the time they or their staffs spent in getting patients needed medication or treatment because of insurance coverage restrictions.

After hours care outside the emergency room. Many American primary care physicians (71%) said they had no arrangement for access to care after normal office hours—except for directing patients to a hospital emergency room. This was a drop from 40% in the 2006 international health policy survey, Schoen said.

On the other hand, nearly all physicians in the Netherlands (97%), and many in New Zealand (89%) and the U.K (89%) report after-hour provision, as do more than three of four doctors in France (78%) and Italy (77%).

Health information technology. While about half (46%) of U.S. primary care physicians reported using electronic medical records (EMR)—up from 28% in 2006—American primary care practices, along with those in Canada, continued to lag behind other leading countries. EMRs were found in nearly all practices in the Netherlands (99%), New Zealand (97%), the U.K. (96%), Australia (95%), Italy (94%), Norway (97%), and Sweden (94%).

Comments are moderated. Please be patient.




FREE e-Newsletters Join the Council Subscribe to HL magazine


100 Winners Circle Suite 300
Brentwood, TN 37027


About | Advertise | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Reprints/Permissions | Contact
© HealthLeaders Media 2016 a division of BLR All rights reserved.